An article on Mint.com, (http://www.mint.com/blog/trends/married-separate-accounts-04292011/)
peeked my interest because I have evolving opinions on the topic. I can only
speak anecdotally based off of my own personal experience. The article, which I
assumed would suggest arbitrarily joining accounts, per most financial advice I
receive, actually affirmed my current decision to maintain separate accounts.
The article states, “If one partner has poor credit
or is paying down debt. Few people enter marriage without at least a little
financial baggage, but if one partner has serious black marks on his
record—bankruptcy, foreclosure, overdue student loans—it is wiser to make
payments from a personal checking account.” This is exactly what we had to
confront when we got married.
I had been very careful and my
husband wasn’t even sure what debts he had in his name. Some of this was
complicated by my FIL’s negligence (a kinder word than what I really mean, dishonesty),
and some of it was the product of bad financial advice. One this was clear, my
husband did not even understand the basic aspects of money. He had a checking
account, with no savings and massive debt. Money would go in when he made it
and it would gush out into whatever he wanted.
My biggest regret with getting
married when we did is that my husband never completely lived on his own. At
the time, it would have seemed silly to have him move out and support himself
for a period of time without roommates, parents and outside influences. Now I
realize that he would have greatly benefitted from working and paying his own
bills. He could have learned how to actually manage money. Seriously, some of
the exercizes we’ve done in the course of our marriage are ideas I pulled from
parenting magazines on how to teach kids responsibility. I don’t mean for that
to sound demeaning, rather, I was lost as to how to show him how finances work
on the simplest level.
When we married, I realized I had
to completely limit his access. He agreed and handed over everything. His bank
statements had been a maze, each month they were about ten sheets of paper
because he had that many small pointless transactions. We set the goal of
keeping his transactions to one page for the monthly statement. That meant he
could really only buy gas on his card. And it had to be planned and budgeted
because he wasn’t carrying it on his person.
So, his account was simple. Buy gas
on a budget. Anything left would go into his newly created savings account. He
wasn’t allowed to withdraw savings. After a period of time (kind of like an
addict) he no longer spent money on impulse. It was a thought process. So, we
started dividing up the bills between our accounts so he could learn to
remember deadlines. We started with the internet bill. Each month, he paid the
internet and bought gas. Gradually, we started merging the use for the
accounts, and added allowances.
He now understands the value of
keeping finances clear and tracking what was spent. Mint.com helps us keep
separate accounts while using money together. Since I make more, more bills
come out of mine. We get the same amount of personal money, though. Any
purchase is discussed before it is made. Usually, we shop together. If one of
us is going alone, we discuss what we think is reasonable for the purchase. We
do a lot of buying research together as well.
After paying off a car together,
and greatly reducing his student loans, we’ve learned to discuss money without
getting personal. There are some imbalances but, mostly, the division seems
fair. We have to compromise. I let him get 2 lunches out per week with friends
but, I haven’t let him buy a massive flat screen. He lets me buy new clothes
but, we’re waiting for the loan to be paid off before decorating the apartment.
Below are a few basic points that keep us sane.
- We talk about everything
- We don’t make assumptions about the other person’s opinion
- It’s not personal or a reflection on character
- Experiences are more important than things
- I love him
Have you found a balance concerning money in your relationship?
Chatboard (1)